Question to Neri and other supporters of Harry as horcrux

[zgirnius]

No: HPFGUIDX 155445

Alla wrote:
> So, to anybody who thinks that Harry is a Horcrux, what is your 
> interpretation of Dumbledore's remark, especially since JKR said 
> that Dumbledore's guesses are never far off mark ( paraphrase), I 
> think specifically in relation to horcruxes?
> 
> Do you think Dumbledore is lying here? Do you think he does not 
know?
> 
> Do you think that Harry's soul somehow could be "untarnished and 
> whole" with the piece of Voldy sould attached to it? ( I confess I 
> find this interpretation to be highly unlikely)

zgirnius:
I have no strong opinion; certainly, I think Harry being a Horcrux is 
not ruled out by anything in the books.

I think the solution to your conundrum is that Voldemort's soul bit 
is not attached to Harry's soul, but to Harry's body (perhaps, 
specifically, his scar). So, Harry's body has, like every other body 
not Kissed by a Dementor, a soul. In Harry's case, that soul is whole 
and untarnished. Unusually, it also has attached to it in a different 
way (via the Horcrux process) a small bit of Voldemort's soul.