Voldemorts Wand/ Accidental Harrycrux : another question
zanooda2
zanooda2 at yahoo.com
Thu Jul 20 01:29:50 UTC 2006
No: HPFGUIDX 155673
> Tonks wrote:
><SNIP>
> Here is a thought. Would it have been possible that there were
> enchantments on the place such that the secret keeper would have had
> to go with the person (LV) in order for the second person (LV) to be
> able to get in?
zanooda:
You mean some protective enchantments in addition to the Fidelius
Charm, right? This is an interesting idea, although there is nothing
in the books to confirm it (for now). But even if there are no such
enchantments, I still believe it's very likely Wormtail was at
Godric's Hollow.
LV would want to take him along to be sure that it was not a trap. If
you have an informant that you don't trust much, wouldn't you want to
take him with you for some kind of guarantee? LV doesn't seem to need
this precaution because of his Legilimency skill ("The Dark Lord
almost always knows when somebody is lying to him"), but he could
suspect that the whole thing was some DD's trick, for example that DD
altered Pettigrew's memory to lure him (LV) to GH alone. So I think
that PP was there, maybe not inside the house, but somewhere around.
As for PP not having LV's wand on him when Lupin and Black transformed
him (someone asked this question, don't remember who, sorry), I think
that he had a lot of opportunities to hide it either between GH and
his confrontation with Sirius, or even later, because I doubt that he
lived 12 years as a rat without turning into a man even once.
> Luna wrote:
><SNIP>
> Harry could posses Voldemort and fill him with this Agape
> love until Voldemort and the piece of soul in Voldemort's body dies.
> If Harry is a Horcrux and if he survives, then the only bit of
> Voldemort left would be Harry or Harry's scar. Harry will have to
> live with it, this will be his cross.
zanooda:
But if Harry is a Horcrux, doesn't it mean that LV cannot be truly
dead in the scenario that you described? If Harry will still have LV's
piece of soul in him after killing LV, as you say, wouldn't he (LV)
turn into Vapormot again, waiting for an opportunity to get a new
body? This is how I understand it, anyway.
Harry's goal is to destroy LV for good, and if he is a Horcrux...
I don't believe for a second that Harry will die, so I hope She will
find some way around it :-)
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive