[HPforGrownups] RE Snape and Petunia

[Kathryn Jones]

No: HPFGUIDX 155686

katssirius wrote:

> Second Ewwwww it would be so creepy if Harry had to have the Voldy soul 
> piece sucked out of him.  I am a believer in the Harry as horcrux 
> theory, but I always thought that meant he would have to sacrifice 
> himself.  What an idea.  To have a partial kiss from a dementor.  Ick 
> and double Ick.  Still it is an idea with merit just very icky.
> 
> katssirius

   KJ writes:

     I find that idea rather disturbing as well. I think that JKR will 
let Harry go with dignity and honour rather than have him be kissed by a 
dementor just so he can live. The books seem to have a "death before 
dishonour" theme and the phrase, "neither can live while the other 
survives", doesn't seem to guarantee that either will survive. Sirius 
could have lived while trapped in the house but chose otherwise. Lily 
could have chosen to live but did not. What will Harry choose?

KJ