Harry's fate WAS: Re: RE Snape and Petunia

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 155689

>    KJ writes:
> 
>      I find that idea rather disturbing as well. I think that JKR 
will 
> let Harry go with dignity and honour rather than have him be 
kissed 
by a 
> dementor just so he can live. The books seem to have a "death 
before 
> dishonour" theme and the phrase, "neither can live while the other 
> survives", doesn't seem to guarantee that either will survive. 
Sirius 
> could have lived while trapped in the house but chose otherwise. 
Lily 
> could have chosen to live but did not. What will Harry choose?


Alla:

I think that if Harry will be kissed by the Dementor, that would 
somehow be rather different from ""normal"" dementor kiss, if such 
even exists, normal I mean.


In any event, I certainy don't think that if Harry lives that would 
be because he would do anything dishonorable just to survive. I 
predict Harry fully ready to sacrifice 
himself, but miraculously saved by fate in some way ( don't ask me 
how), while nobody, especially Harry will think that it is possible.

Besides, there are several other possibilities suggested to let 
Harry 
as Horcrux live, Dementor kiss is not the only one.

I seem to remember Debbie suggested Voldie piece dissappear in a 
really elegant way, but don't remember the details. :)

I think Dementor kiss maybe reserved for Voldie or not. We shall see.

Another one was Voldie piece integrating with Harry soul or 
something like that and becoming "pure"

Besides, I am still not sure that Harry **is** a Horcrux, 
since "untarnished and whole" soul buggs me still.

Alla, who sadly realises that Harry's death would be the only plot 
twist that would make her say good bye to the books.

No, I would not throw them away, they gave me too much enjoyment, 
but 
I would not reread them, knowing that there is no hope for Harry to 
survive.