Whose side are we on?? :was: Arthur right or not?

[lupinlore]

No: HPFGUIDX 156133


> Ceridwen:
> What I didn't get was that they all passed over what happened to
> Ginny in CoS, with barely more than a warning not to trust objects
> that have their own minds.  I think this was a set-up for the
later
> reactions to Umbridge.  No one liked what happened to Ginny, no
one
> liked what happened to Harry.  But, stiff upper lip, pip-pip, all
> that, nothing more to see here, move along...
>

You might be on to something here.  I would agree that "vile" is a
rather good word for it, or at the very least "ignoble."  I often
really wonder why anyone -- meaning Harry -- really cares what
happens to these ignoble morons.  Of course, Harry does have a
personal stake in it.  Which gets us back to the revenge theme.


Lupinlore