Eileen Pince
colebiancardi
muellem at bc.edu
Mon Jul 31 20:16:43 UTC 2006
No: HPFGUIDX 156260
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "abergoat" <adescour at ...> wrote:
>
> The presence of a picture implies they were
> participating in an international competition (the Daily Prophet
> doesn't seem to be interested in Harry's quidditch captaincy - only
> his tri-wizard champion post). Doesn't this sound like a clue that the
> woman cowering in Snape's OoP memory was not Eileen? Why would a
> magical Eileen with the leadership skills to captain an international
> team cower in front of a MUGGLE husband? Seems unlikely. I bet JKR
> wanted us to question Harry's assumption that those people were
> Snape's parents rather than some other relatives.
>
colebiancardi:
I still think those people were Snape's parents. As far as why would a
woman who has a strong character cower in front of her husband - ask
any woman who was in an abusive marriage - ask her if her character
changed when confronted by her husband and she reacted in a manner that
her friends and family would say is out of character for her.
I speak from experience.
colebiancardi...
(love & fear: a deadly combination that, at best, makes us fools)
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive