Hagrid.

[eggplant107]

No: HPFGUIDX 153437

steven1965aaa at ...> wrote: 

> It is my belief that IF Dumbledore is
> not dead, that Hagrid is in on it. 

Yes he'd have to be, but do you really think Hagrid is that good an
actor, do you think he has the ability to pretend to be sad when he
really isn't? I don't. Of all the characters in the Potter books
Hagrid is the one with the least guile, what you see is what you get.
And why on earth would JKR want to bring Dumbledore back from the
dead, what a huge anticlimax that would be! JKR wants us to understand
this is serious business, people are going to die, even very good people. 

Right after book 4 came out I predicted that Dumbledore would die at
the end of book 6; it makes a great cliff hanger and you can't have a
very powerful wizard like Dumbledore waiting in the wings ready to
take over if Harry fails to defeat Voldemort. It's all up to Harry and
nobody else. 

Eggplant