Understanding Snape--Pensieve scene
Darlene Carroll
honeykissed246 at yahoo.com
Tue Jun 13 03:27:10 UTC 2006
No: HPFGUIDX 153776
Julie:
Snip> "We know that Harry saw Snape put
three "memories" into the pensieve before the start of the
interrupted and final lesson. But what is there in canon as proof
that the memory Harry saw was **Snape's** memory--one of the three?
Or that all three were of James' misdeeds? Surely there are other
things that Snape would not want Harry to see."
Honeykissed:
You know, I wondered about that as well. I believe that there was "something" between Lilly and Snape. Now I am not saying a "relationship" per se, but there is something. I would think that whatever it is or was, Snape would not want Harry to know about it. I think this may have been one of the three that he removed. Also, I am inclined to think that Dumbledore may leave the pensieve to Harry (we have yet to see). Since Dumbledore died, Snape left (abruptly :)) maybe Harry will find some "bottled up" memories that he can use. I am definitely curious to see what the other two memories consisted of. But I defintely agree with you....its very interesting.
I hope I posted this correctly so the powers that be will not chose to delete it.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive