Evil Snape

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 154231

> Nikkalmati
 Possibly,  Snape will die for the 
> cause and Harry will feel guilty?  Possibly, we will  see a 
parallel with the 
> Prank.  If James was so appalled at the near death  of Severus that 
he gave up his 
> juvenile ways,  Harry could be shocked out  of his own hostility 
and 
> arrogance by something Snape does.   

Alla:

Ok, I can see as a possibility that Harry was wrong about Snape. I 
mean, I hope it does not happen, but I always try to keep alternate 
possibilities in mind in order not to be too dissapointed, but this 
argument I cannot even see where you are coming from.

Harry's arrogance about Snape? Harry was standing on the Tower, 
helpless, paralyzed and was forced to watch Snape kill Dumbledore for 
whatever reasons.

Even if it IS a mistake, is it an ARROGANT mistake to make?

Harry was trying so hard to get DD home to get help for him, here 
comes Severus dearest and deals with Harry's beloved mentor very fast.

Um, why is it arrogant on Harry behalf to desire to bring Snape to 
justice?

As I said, I can see that it COULD be a mistake, but I see it as a 
very reasonable, understandable mistake, IF it is a mistake of course.

JMO,
Alla.