Evil Snape

[Darlene Carroll]

No: HPFGUIDX 154267

Nikkalmati:
"that is the climax and I think somewhere in Book 7 Harry's view 
of Snape will be shown to be completely wrong".

Honeykissed:
Just like Harry was wrong about Sirius in POA , I think he is also 
wrong about Snape. We shall see if he figures it out before he goes 
"Snape" hunting. 

Sherry now:
>> I disagree. It is time for Harry to take on his true role as 
hero, and it's time for his judgment to be correct. The torch has 
passed from Dumbledore to Harry, and I think it diminishes him if 
his judgment is wrong again. It would be ironic, if after all these 
years of everyone telling him he was wrong about Snape, and now he 
is proven right. It's about time. <<

Honeykissed:
Hummmm...I believe part of Dumbledore's greatness was his ability 
to admit that he was wrong in some incidences.  I do not believe 
that Harry is right about Snape and I don't think it diminishes his 
judgment if he if found to be incorrect.  I think at this point Snape 
will become Harry's greatest asset.  Just like Snape was "teaching" 
Harry in HBP and Harry didn't even know it. :)  Harry will still be 
the "hero" but he is going to need help and I think he will need 
Snape's help, one way or the other.