Was Severus in the Slug Club? (Was: Snape liked Hogwarts? )

[potioncat]

No: HPFGUIDX 154392

 
> Leslie41:
> Ditto.  Slughorn obviously chooses students he feels will do him 
> good, whom he feels will reflect well on him. It's really 
> disgusting, his little club.  I can't imagine Snape being in it.  I 
> can't imagine either Snape liking Slughorn, or the way he cozies up 
> to the students.


Potioncat:
No matter how well we each make our point--Snape was or was not in the 
Club--we still don't know. Both sides have come up with good theories, 
but much of it is assumption. 

Neither Hermione or Ginny have any ethical problems attending the Slug 
Club. Nor do I think Snape would refuse to be in the club. Still we 
don't know.

We only see Snape and Trelawney. We don't see the invitation list. Nor 
do we know for sure that other teachers weren't there either while 
Harry was there (but he didn't see them) or that they came afterwards.

Now, how many think Minerva was in the Slug Club?