DD death

[minerva_523]

No: HPFGUIDX 154527


> Najwa wrote:
<SNIP>
> This is true, he has a quick tongue,so I suppose he might have worded
> it in a way that he can think of that might be able to change how he
> could react to it, sort of like when we were all kids and someone asks
> you if what you said was true and you reply "I SWEAR!" and then mumble
> "that my name is <insert name here>" under your breath. I could see
> Snape doing something to that effect, only of course in a more mature
> way and twisting his words so that they sound like he's agreeing but
> there's a catch that only the quick witted and focused will notice,
> both of which I fall short of at times. Kudos to you bboyminn for that
> point, and to you as well cacaia for helping me understand his point
> better :). However, now I am baffled as to what to think, because I
> was relying on my theory that DD did this to get Snape and Draco out
> of harm's way, along with letting Voldie think that he's got dibs on
> Hogwarts. Hmmm, this is hurting my Snape had to kill Dumbledore for
> some heroic cause theory...Any Snape fans mind helping me back into
> thinking he's really a good guy after all again?
>
And Cacaia's back to respond:
Yes, here's a Snape fan if there ever was one ;-) I, unfortunately,
don't have my book with me, but- do you recall the scene in which
Hagrid told Harry about what he overheard behind closed doors?
Dumbledore and Snape were having a pretty heated argument, in which
Dumbledore said something like "do your job" to Snape- could this
possibly mean he intended Snape to kill him, and Snape downright
refused? There's got to be something planned- Dumbledore, IMO,
intended to die- I don't know necessarily why he intended to
incriminate Snape, though- it's all very mysterious:-)
Cacaia