DD death

[honeykissed246]

No: HPFGUIDX 154567


> > Najwa wrote:
<Snip>
> this is hurting my Snape had to kill Dumbledore for some heroic 
cause theory...Any Snape fans mind helping me back into thinking 
he's really a good guy after all again?

> Cacaia wrote:
> Yes, here's a Snape fan if there ever was one ;-) I, unfortunately,
> don't have my book with me, but- do you recall the scene in which
> Hagrid told Harry about what he overheard behind closed doors?
> Dumbledore and Snape were having a pretty heated argument, in which
> Dumbledore said something like "do your job" to Snape- could this
> possibly mean he intended Snape to kill him, and Snape downright
> refused? There's got to be something planned- Dumbledore, IMO,
> intended to die- I don't know necessarily why he intended to
> incriminate Snape, though- it's all very mysterious:-)

Honeykissed:
I also think Snape is innocent and playing for the DD side.  I think 
DD used Snape because he knew that people (including LV) would buy 
it.  Here is Snape, former DE, Potters killer, horrible attitude, 
all of a sudden he is remorseful, but no one but "old" DD trust 
him.  But DD isn't telling anyone "why" he trust him.  Not only 
that, if he shared this information with anyone else, he risked it 
getting out and destroying the entire plan.  I am convinced that DD 
told Snape that he would have to kill him and made him promise (just 
like he did Harry in the cave scene).  I don't think Snape wanted to 
do it but had to.  Snape had a fairly decent job, was HOH and 
protected and he let all of that go for the sake of saving the WW 
(IMO).  Now everyone thinks he is a murderer and playing for LV.  I 
don't think this is the case and we will see how it plays out in 
book 7.  

Honeykissed :)