[HPforGrownups] Snape Survey

[Kathy King]

No: HPFGUIDX 148937

On 2/28/06, Luckdragon <luckdragon64 at yahoo.ca> wrote:
>
> Luckdragon:
> Everytime I read my HP for Grownups email I see pages and pages of
> Snape. I don't think we will see the end of the "Is Snape ESE or ESG
> or OFH" until book seven is released; so, just for the sake of being
> able to tell each other "I told you so", let's tally up what we
> believe Snape is before we actually know, and see which way the
> majority of us are thinking. A brief paragraph is sufficient.
>
> Myself for example, I am somewhat like DD and just have to look for
> the good in people, so obviously I believe Snape will be found out to
> be ESG. Well maybe not good exactly, but neither ESE or OFH. Lupin
> said it well in book six; " It comes down to whether or not you trust
> Dumbledore's judgement. I do; therefore, I trust Severus." (Chpt 16)
>
> So in your Opinion, who's side is Snape on?
>
>
> Snow:




Can I choose another category because Snape isn't just DDM or OFH or ESE,
Snape is a combination of all of them, which is why he is talked about more
than the main character of the books, and no one seems to be quite
comfortable with any conclusion they come to. Snape was ESE and he has to
trust Dumbledore and be DDM in order to be OFH. The conclusion I came to is;
that Snape split his soul and wants to repair it to make himself whole.
Dumbledore informed Snape that he had a chance of accomplishing this mission
but he had to commit an act that would be worthy of at least the Order of
Merlin to repair the damage.



Just my summary of ESE Snape who became DDM in order to be OFH in the end



Snow


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]