Snape Survey

[h2so3f]

No: HPFGUIDX 148982

Luckdragon  wrote:  <SNIP>
"Just for the sake of being able to tell each other "I told you so", 
let's tally up what we believe Snape is before we actually know, and 
see which way the majority of us are thinking. A brief paragraph is 
sufficient."


CH3ed:
I am going with DDM!Snape. I was shaken by "Spinner's End" Chapter 
in HBP because the Snape there could belong to either DD's or LV's 
camp. But, strangely enough, while the argument Snape had with DD in 
the forest that Hagrid overheard added weight to Snape being ESE, it 
was his AKing DD on the Tower and his teaching and protecting of 
Harry during his flight that convinced me he is DDM. I'm convinced 
DD would never plead for his own life, and I don't think that DD 
loved Snape like he did Harry. So I think that had DD felt betrayed 
by Snape on the Tower he wouldn't have pleaded. I think he would 
have stayed silent on the outside while berating Snape loudly via 
ligilimency, but there would be no pleading. So IMO on the Tower DD 
pleaded with Snape to sacrifice DD to salvage the lousy situation 
they found themselves in and save Harry & Draco (and get the DEs 
away from Hogswart).

CH3ed :O)