Snape Survey, Snapeity, Dumbledore's sacrifice.

[eggplant107]

No: HPFGUIDX 149272

"sistermagpie" <belviso at ...> wrote:

> Even in your own explanation of the 
> story, it seems that whenever it comes
> time for a change to occur in Dumbledore,
> it's never there in the text and always
> has to be imagined or rewritten.

Well one second Dumbledore is ill but cool calm and collected and the
next second he's pleading, so something has certainly changed in
Dumbledore's mind. True, we don't hear Dumbledore thinking "I just had
a terrible thought and I don't like the look on Severus's face" but we
never hear what Dumbledore is thinking or any other character except
Harry. And it's true Dumbledore didn't explain his change of mind
verbally either, but then Snape only gave him time to say 2 words
before he blasted him to death. Let me repeat, he blasted Dumbledore
to death. Why are we still debating if Snape is a villain?

Eggplant