[HPforGrownups] Re: The end of the Secret (Was: The lack of Obliviators and the Press at GH )

Karen kchuplis at alltel.net
Wed Mar 22 20:06:58 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 149902



  PJ wrote: 
  > As for how Dumbledore knew the Potters were in trouble and where
  they  were... When you worry about people you think about them a lot.
  As long as Dumbledore could think about them and not visualize where
  they were located he knew they were ok, but the minute he *knew* where
  they were, he knew the secret was out - and also where to send Hagrid.

  Carol responds:
  I agree with you here: Dumbledore did *not* know where they were
  because Peter had not told him. (Obviously Peter had not told him in
  person or DD would have known that Black was not the SD, but I don't
  think he received a note, either.) But, yes, the moment he knew the
  Secret, he knew that the Potters were in trouble and probably dead.

  kchuplis:

  Soooo. Is there maybe something here that explains why it took Hagrid so long? What if there was something DD had Hagrid do in order to find the rubble and Harry? 

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]





More information about the HPforGrownups archive