TBAY: HMS DESIRE (about Snape) Long

[veroniki travlou]

No: HPFGUIDX 149944

Nikkalmati wrote: 

> A wild and loopy suggestion <g>.  What if James 
> made Snape repay his life 
> debt by preparing a love potion for Lily?  Being 
> smarter than Voldemort's 
> mother, he never stopped giving it to her.   Even
> Harry wondered how his father 
> ever got his mother to like him, after he had  seen
> the scene in the Pensive and 
> a love potion crossed his mind. I bet Snape  would
> really feel good about 
> James then!

vera:

I think if aything like that took place, it will be
very disappointing..
I hate to think that James forced Lily to love him
like that.

I'm under the impression that an event, we know nothing
about, took place, which made the two of them get
together in the end. Something life threatening
perhaps which made James's courageous and charming side
come out. Snape could have been involved somehow. I
don't doubt that Snape could have had a crush on Lily.
By the sound of her many people could have fallen in
love with her(..Lupin..why not?). I'm sure Lily chose
James for a reason.

Anyway, if Dumbledore is just dead, James drugged Lily
to love him and Snape is just a death eater then
what's left to theorize on?

cheers,

vera