LID!Snape rides again (was: High Noon for OFH!Snape)

[xuxunette]

No: HPFGUIDX 150001

I didn't really follow the thread but I had to agree with something in
this post.

Lupinlore: snip
>I think JKR is honestly taken aback by fan 
> reactions to certain things.  Once again, as I've said before, JKR 
> is often a victim of the problem of three:  What she thinks she's 
> writing, what we read, and what's actually there are three different 
> things, and often don't have that much resemblance to one another.

That's so true. And  I think the reason why most of the (very
enjoyable) theories thought up in this group seem often too far
fetched to me is that what we read is often not even what we really
read, but what we wanted to read. 

xuxu