Re Fake Secret Keeper/

[pippin_999]

No: HPFGUIDX 150109


> Pippin wrote in
> http://groups.yahoo.com/group/HPforGrownups/message/150028 :
> 
> << The switch wouldn't have protected the secret from Voldemort for
> long. (snip) But it might have worked as an attempt to expose the spy.
> If Sirius gave the "secret" in written form to the person he
> suspected, and  Voldemort attacked on that information, the spy would
> be revealed. >>

Catlady:
Sirius should have given a fake secret in his own writing to
> someone who would be able to read it because it was a fake secret?
> 
> I guess that last one kind of makes sense, give a different fake
> address to each member of the Order and wait to see which fake address
> is attacked. Unless there are two spies and LV notices that each one
> brought him a different address which can't both be right...

Pippin:
Sirius does not suspect every member of the Order. He thinks that
Lupin is the spy. But it seems that he couldn't prove it, or he would
have either confronted Lupin or taken the evidence to Dumbledore.

If Sirius gives a fake secret to Lupin in his own  handwriting, and 
Voldemort shows up to attack that place, then Sirius will have proof.  

Pippin