Lily' sacrifice v James' sacrifice WAS: Perfect Lily

H.M.S h.m.s at mweb.co.za
Wed Mar 29 09:30:47 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 150229

(Parts snipped)
Carol:
"It's Lily's choice that distinguishes her from
James, who also died bravely defending his family."

Has anyone considered that Lily positively KNEW (in herself) that Voldy
would kill Harry regardless of any bargain that she might strike with him
and so (sort of) committed suicide because she could not bear the loss of
her baby.  A sort of "I can't be with him in life, but I will be with him (&
James) in death".  We hear of these sort of suicide pacts in the news all
the time.

Sharon
(who doesn't really believe this theory - but thought to stir the pot a bit)





More information about the HPforGrownups archive