Snape, Snape, always Snape! (was Re: Amortentia and re The morality of love pot

[juli17ptf]

No: HPFGUIDX 152385

Alla wrote:
> Merope did not deserve to die. Nobody deserves to die ( well, except 
> maybe Snape), but neither did Tom deserved any misery this woman 
> inflicted upon him.
> 
> JMO,
> 
> Alla

Nobody except *maybe SNAPE*? Not Voldemort, who's orchestrated the 
murder of dozens? Not Fenrir, who eats children? Not Peter, a repeat 
murderer and betrayer of best friends? Not Bellatrix, Lucius Malfoy, or 
any of a dozen other vicious, torturing, murdering Death Eaters? Not 
that *%&#(% child abuser Umbridge? Just the meanest professor this side 
of Muggleland, Snape? 

Okay, admittedly he may or may not have cold-bloodedly murdered 
Dumbledore, but still! Why, oh why, must poor Snape be so horribly 
demonized compared to the other true monsters in the WW? 

Julie
deflecting an increasingly bitter debate back to our favorite subject ;-
)