The Dome Effect in GOF
gelite67
gelite67 at yahoo.com
Sat May 20 15:04:11 UTC 2006
No: HPFGUIDX 152537
When Harry's wand locked with LV's wand in the graveyard, they
produced a golden, dome shaped web that separated Harry and LV from
the DEs.
LV then orders the DEs to "do nothing."
Several things I've never understood about this scene.
First, was this "dome effect" part of the Priori Incantatem b/c Harry
and LV? The effect itself was only described as "rare" and as
forcing one of the wands to reveal the brother wand's prior spells.
Nothing about any protective domes.
Second, if this is part of the PI effect, was is unique to Harry and
LV or would it have occurred b/w any two wizards whose wands came
from the same phoenix? And by the same phoenix, I don't mean Fawkes,
I just mean any "same" phoenix?
Third, if the dome effect is not part of the PI spell, then what
caused it? It's clearly related to Fawkes b/c Harry heard/felt the
phoenix's song emanating from the dome. He felt the song inside of
him, which he connected with DD, and felt as though a friend was
whispering in his ear, "Don't break the connection." GOF, U.S
softcover at 664.
I tend to think that this was not a normal part of the PI effect, but
was an additional effect that was only activated because the PI
effect betweem Harry's wand and LV's wand was activated. It seems to
be part of the "mysterious" protection that always seems to favor
Harry, but what caused it? Perhaps something Ollivander did to the
brother wand after he saw what Tom Riddle had become??? When Harry
explains to DD and Sirius what happened in the graveyard and DD
explains the PI to Harry, DD mentions nothing about the protective
dome, which suggests that DD isn't surprised about it.
Finally, could the DEs have done anything if LV had wanted them too?
I don't think they could have, but I don't really have anything to
support that, other than the protection of the dome would have been
pretty futile of it could have been broken from the outside.
Angie (wishing everyone a happy Saturday)
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive