DD death
minerva_523
minerva_523 at yahoo.com
Tue May 23 19:08:27 UTC 2006
No: HPFGUIDX 152754
> > bboyminn wrote:
> > So, my point is that to unbind yourself from a Vow, you must either
> > word the Vow very precisely so that it has a clear end, or you must
> > gather the involved people together and cast the magical unbinding
> Charm.
>
> Najwa wrote:
> ...I think the only way to undo it is for Snape not to have gone through
> with it and just died.
Cacaia's opinion:
Now,as bboyminn has mentioned:I agree that to weasel oneself out of
such a thing as an unbreakable vow, one must use some wordplay. I
think Snape could have gotten out of this one by saying something to
the effect of: "If the Dark Lord wills it, I will carry on with
Draco's task"- as opposed to the flat and simple, "yes" he gave Narcissa.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive