DD death

[Najwa]

No: HPFGUIDX 152774


> > > bboyminn wrote:
> > > So, my point is that to unbind yourself from a Vow, you must either
> > > word the Vow very precisely so that it has a clear end, or you must
> > > gather the involved people together and cast the magical unbinding
> > Charm. 
> > 
> Cacaia's opinion:
> Now,as bboyminn has mentioned:I agree that to weasel oneself out of
> such a thing as an unbreakable vow, one must use some wordplay. I
> think Snape could have gotten out of this one by saying something to
> the effect of: "If the Dark Lord wills it, I will carry on with
> Draco's task"- as opposed to the flat and simple, "yes" he gave
Narcissa.
>
Najwa:
This is true, he has a quick tongue,so I suppose he might have worded
it in a way that he can think of that might be able to change how he
could react to it, sort of like when we were all kids and someone asks
you if what you said was true and you reply "I SWEAR!" and then mumble
"that my name is <insert name here>" under your breath. I could see
Snape doing something to that effect, only of course in a more mature
way and twisting his words so that they sound like he's agreeing but
there's a catch that only the quick witted and focused will notice,
both of which I fall short of at times. Kudos to you bboyminn for that
point, and to you as well cacaia for helping me understand his point
better :). However, now I am baffled as to what to think, because I
was relying on my theory that DD did this to get Snape and Draco out
of harm's way, along with letting Voldie think that he's got dibs on
Hogwarts. Hmmm, this is hurting my Snape had to kill Dumbledore for
some heroic cause theory...Any Snape fans mind helping me back into
thinking he's really a good guy after all again?