DD death

[Barbara Kraus]

No: HPFGUIDX 152776

Najwa wrote:
><snip> I cannot begin to understand why this death was needed, but I 
>highly doubt he would die in that manner to Snape without there being 
>a reason, <snip> perhaps to let LV think that he can get his way with 
>Harry and Hogwarts. <snip> 

Ffred:
> Not sure if this idea has ever been floated, but what if Dumbledore 
> chose to be killed in order to save Draco's life? <snip>


bjk5377:
I've not posted here before and just started reading the board about a 
week ago...so I'm sure this has been discussed in detail.  Are we sure 
DD's dead?  When Harry thought he saw a phoenix rise out of the flames 
around DD's coffin, could that not have been DD?  I wonder why he would 
die to save the life of a death-eater-in-training...