Did Dumbly Deserve what he got?

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 152934

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "divya_thomas1" 
<divya_thomas1 at ...> wrote:
>
> Personally, I think he deserved what he got for trusting Snape. Snape
> was evil and everyone knowing the fact he was a death eater did not
> trust him. And Maybe if there is an unbreakable vow between Snape and
> Dumbledore, it would have been cancelled the moment he killed
> Dumbledore and Snape must have planned this all the way. Any 
Arguments?


Alla:

Hehe. You won't get any arguments from me that  the possibility that 
DD trust in Snape was, how would we put it.... not justified. But that 
is as Ceridwen said ... all we left with is speculation, since we 
don't know for sure the reason why. Believe me, if DD trust WAS 
justified, I would want a VERY good reason for that.

But no, I don't think that DD got what he deserved. How can giving 
people second chances can ever be wrong? Now those people throwing 
away those second chances, that's tragic, yes. IMO.

Oh, and I don't see DD as person making any kind of UVs. They seem 
kind of dark to me too and as we know DD does not like doing dark 
magic. :)

Oh, and while I think that Snape killed DD because he was saving 
himself, NOT because DD ordered him to do so, I unfortunately don't 
think that Snape planned it all along.

Unfortunately, I think that Snape truly felt trapped on the Tower. Not 
that I think that he found the best way to deal with it. ;)

JMO,

Alla.