Harry not a Horcrux

[Kishan]

No: HPFGUIDX 161060

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Lana" <unicornspride at ...>
wrote:
> All this talk of Harry being a Horcrux is strange to me..  I
> thought a Horcrux was created with intent??  Am I wrong in this
> thought.  Can a Horcrux be created without the person knowing his
> soul is being transferred?  I was under the impression that LV had
> to create it on purpose.  I do not believe that LV intentionally
> would have made the scar or Harry himself a horcrux.  He was never
> in possession of Harry after the fact, so..  for all purposes in my
> eyes, it is not even possible that Harry or any part of him is a
> Horcrux.  LV would not have had the power to do it after the attacks
> as he was powerless at that time.

Kishan:
Harry can't be a Horcrux.  I mean, think about it, "....neither can live while the other survives" the prophecy clearly states that someone has to kill the other.  So, Voldemort has got to kill Harry.  But if he does, he would be losing a part of his soul.  So I don't think Harry being a horcrux himself is possible.