Snape's teaching moments was CHAPDISC: HBP24, Sectumsempra, #12

Eddie harryp at stararcher.com
Thu Nov 9 20:59:20 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 161332

> now Pat:
> I mostly agree with both zgirnius and Sherry, but since Snape's
> farewell to Harry (post-tower) was obviously a teaching moment, I have
> wondered if there was something that Harry could have learned in this
> or not.  Maybe I'm really over-reaching here, because I haven't been
> able to come up with anything.  Does anyone have any ideas as to what,
> if anything, Harry could have learned?

Eddie:
On face value, Harry could have learned that ultimately he will have a
difficult time against Voldemort if he doesn't learn non-verbal
spell-casting and occlumency.  More subtly, that Snape is first and
foremost his teacher and his ally.  After all, during Snape's
farewell, he had nothing to lose in capturing Harry and taking him to
Voldemort.  Previously, Snape clearly told Bellatrix that the only
reason he never took Harry to Voldemort -- or killed him -- was
because he (Snape) was trying to maintain his cover story.  Well, the
killing of Dumbledore pretty much ended that.

IMHO.

Eddie






More information about the HPforGrownups archive