Harry is Not A Horcrux, But the Sword Is

Kathy ladypensieve at yahoo.com
Thu Nov 9 22:17:26 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 161336

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "bridgetteakabiit" 
<bridgetteakabiit at ...> wrote:
>KathyO:I agree Harry isn't a Horcrux, however I believe that his 
scar either is or contains a Horcrux.
> 
> bridgetteakabiit:
> I am confused. If the scar is, or contains a horcrux, how can it be
destroyed without Harry being destroyed? (snip) If Voldemort can't 
be destroyed until all the horcruxes are destroyed, and Harry's scar 
is the other horcrux, then it sounds like Harry has to be destroyed 
in order for Voldemort to be.

Now Kathy (lol): This is why JKR keeps us on our toes, saying that 
Harry might actually die in the last book. Even if we figure out 
that Harry's scar is a Horcrux, how will this save Harry?  

Can you imagine being Harry?  He still has one last Horcrux to 
destroy before he meets Voldemort, yet it's no where to be found?  
Then the moment comes and he has no choice in the matter...

My personal theory is that Voldemort - in a sense - will kill 
himself when he tries to kill Harry.  The curse will be thrown at 
Harry, the Horcrux will protect itself, sending the curse back to 
Voldemort, as he sees this, he sends another curse at Harry, hitting 
him in the scar.  Both fall to the ground.  Is Harry alive?  Is 
Voldemort?

We have to wait and see what JKR has in store for us - dam it!
KathyO








More information about the HPforGrownups archive