[HPforGrownups] Time turner theory

[inyia]

No: HPFGUIDX 161834

Lana wrote:
I think I read that all the time turners were smashed in the MOM brawl..  But... here is a thought.. Hermoine had one at one point, so what is to say that there isn't one out there that someone else had at the time of the fight.. <snip>

JKR said that she "is not telling" when asked if HP will time travel again..  So, this brings me to think that it is possible for Harry to go back in time to make certain things happen. Or to take certain things that he will need in the future battle with LV. 
<snip> ...what if Harry went back in time and explained to the past DD what was happening in the future. DD would be able to make changes that would affect the future and current HP situation with LV. HP could get things like the locket, or the cup, or even the ring.. Lots of things could change and the end of the book could lead to Harry living happily ever after with his parents and Sirius and DD all alive and it was all as if nothing ever happened.. <snip>


inyia:
Great idea but it's well known that travelling in time in the Harry Potter books doesn't affect the future.

We know that they saved Sirius and Buckbeak but Buckbeak wasn't killed the first time either.
 
On the other hand it would be like the dream theory (all in his head), a little disappointing, don't you think?


inyia