[HPforGrownups] Time turner theory

[Lana]

No: HPFGUIDX 161835

inyia wrote:
Great idea but it's well known that travelling in time in the Harry Potter books doesn't affect the future.

We know that they saved Sirius and Buckbeak but Buckbeak wasn't killed the first time either.

On the other hand it would be like the dream theory (all in his head), a little disappointing, don't you think?

Lana Writes:

But.. Had the kids not gone back in time, Buckbeak would have died.  Hermoine even saw herself, so we KNOW that this is why he didn't die.  They had already taken him.

I must have missed something..  How is it well known that going back will not change the future or affect it?  Freeing Beaky and Sirius is changing the future isn't it?

Lana





 

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]