Which Dumbledore ?

[Chris Tredennick]

No: HPFGUIDX 161906

> Which Dumbledore died at top of the tower? Everyone
> thinks Aberforth is the barman at the Hogs Head. What
> if Albus and Aberforth are twins? JKR says look at
> Dumbledore`s family and says Dumbledore is dead but
> does not use a forname so using this thought which died?
>
> Raymond.


She states in an interview that "the hero has to go on alone".  To me
that sounds like he (Albus) is really dead.
http://www.quick-quote-quill.org/articles/2006/0801-radiocity-pressconf.html

Another interesting thought, we know that Mundungus was banned from
the Hog's Head, and that the barman (Aberforth) has a good memory.
However, we see the two of them in Hogsmead, possibly doing business.
 Why is Aberforth dealing with 'Dung?

Chris