LV, Nagini and Harry

[justcarol67]

No: HPFGUIDX 159088

> > Carol, who still thinks that Nagini was made a Horcrux before Godric's
> > Hollow
> 
> 
> montims:  so you think Nagini was LV's pet before the Potter attack
- do I understand you correctly?  In that case, where would she have
been all those years that LV was vapour in Albania or wherever?  At
the Riddle house?  And whose murder would have led to her horcrux? 
And assuming that she follows normal laws of mortality, she is bound
to die sometime, however much magic is invested in making her
long-lived.  If she died, would her dead body remain a horcrux I wonder?
> 

Carol responds:
Good questions. I don't have time to elaborate on my theory now, but
you can always do a search for "Carol" and "Nagini" as search terms to
bring up old posts.

Obviously, I don't know whose murder was used, but since Grindelwald.
a prime candidate for the other wizard known to have made a Horcrux,
was defeated in 1945 by Dumbledore but not killed by him, I consider
him a possibility. (Tom finds the secret to Horcrux-making, then kills
Grindelwald after Dumbledore destroys his Horcrux. How's that for an
important murder to create a Horcrux with?)

And I have a feeling that she found Voldemort in Albania and was
brought back along with Voldemort by Quirrell. Perhaps Voldemort was
possessing her at the time. That would account for Quirrell's managing
to bring LV from Albania to England before LV began possessing him.

All speculative, of course.

Carol, who has to leave her post unproofread as she's running late!