new to the group

[Lauren]

No: HPFGUIDX 159307


> Bobby:
> Not sure what all has been said on here before however after reading
> Half Blood Prince I began thinking that Dumbledore is not dead. I know
> I have a very good chance of being wrong but it was pointed out in the
> book about how they can perform spells without speaking the. Also why
> would he take Hary to a place that is clearly so dangerous not really
> his style. I think he wanted to let Harry see him get sick and fall to
> Snape! Snape had made the unbreakable vow to kill Dumbledore if
> Malfoy could not so what if he came up with something to make it
> appear that he had done so? Like I said I could be wrong :) And has
> any one figured out the Initials yet? R.A.B. From the chapter Flight
> of the Prince?

Lauren:

An interesting theory. But I think he is dead. JK Rowling has
systematically killed off anyone that Harry could use as a crutch. I
think she is setting it up so the final battle with Voldemort is
Harry's own effort and not the foreplanning of some helpful adult.

It is implied in the book that Dumbledore of the Unbreakable vow. I
like to think that he gave up his life to protect Snape and Draco from
Volemorts wrath.

Lauren