[HPforGrownups] new to the group

[Mare Cad TITANIC]

No: HPFGUIDX 159308

>Bobby Reed wrote:          

>Not sure what all has been said on here before however after reading 
>Half Blood Prince I began thinking that Dumbledore is not dead. 
>I know I have a very good chance of being wrong but it was pointed 
>out in the book about how they can perform spells without speaking
>the. Also why would he take Hary to a place that is clearly so 
>dangerous not really his style. I think he wanted to let Harry see
>him get sick and fall to Snape! Snape had made the unbreakable vow 
>to kill Dumbledore if Malfoy could not so what if he came up with
>something to make it appear that he had done so? 

>Like I said I could be wrong :) And has any one figured out the
>Initials yet? R.A.B. From the chapter Flight of the Prince? 


Marianne:

Does anyone know the full name of Professor Binns ? He could be the RAB  we are speaking of.  His love of  History & his accuracy in it, could make him  responsible for destroying one of the Horcruxes. He alwys seemed to me, to be a good guy !!! 
    
Marianne ( Mare ) CadTITANIC

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]