HBP theories...

[Kayla Pittillo]

No: HPFGUIDX 159478

> x_dreamsmadeflesh_x <x_dreamsmadeflesh_x@> wrote:
>
> Theory #1: Dumbledore is not really dead. Maybe Dumbledore and
> Snape used polyjuice potion and switched. I was thinking that
> maybe Snape felt that he owed Dumbledore one last favor and
> switched because he knew Lord Voldemort's plans to kill Dumbledore.
> Does anyone else think this might be true?


Kayla:
What about Fawkes? Traditionally phoenixes are lone creatures that
take with one person if at all, and Fawkes was seen mourning at
DD's funeral. That to me would indicate that Dumbledore is indeed
dead and that it wasn't a polyjuiced Snape. Fawkes would have no
reason to mourn Snape, imo. Aside from Fawkes, I don't see any
reason why Dumbledore would switch places with Snape, and I don't
see how it could be done without at least some of the DEs being
suspicious and trying to gang up on polyjuiced DD in the tower,
mainly Fenrir Greyback.

Kayla