The Scar

Jim Ferer jferer at yahoo.com
Sun Oct 15 12:08:52 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 159728

Jeff: "I've been having my first discussion with another member, and we
disagree on the seventh horcrux.  She feels it is Nagini, and I cannot
help but feel it is Harry's scar (because of the powers he got from
Voldemort)."

The Horcrux being Harry's scar (or Harry himself) doesn't meet the 
conditions for creating a Horcrux as we know them, which seem to
require a lot of preparation by Voldemort. He certainly didn't go to
Harry's home intending to create one, he intended to off Harry.  

But there could be some way a semi-demi-defective kind of horcrux
could be created by accident, maybe the last tiny bit of evil that has
to be destroyed to make Voldemort's destruction complete.  One thing I
still believe is that Voldemort's final destruction will require a
tremendous sacrifice from Harry, more than Harry's own life.

Jim Ferer






More information about the HPforGrownups archive