The Scar
Kenneth Clark
kennclark at btinternet.com
Sun Oct 15 13:29:22 UTC 2006
No: HPFGUIDX 159742
Jeff <fluorite at ...> wrote:
> I've been having my first discussion with another member,
> and we disagree on the seventh horcrux. She feels it is
> Nagini, and I cannot help but feel it is Harry's scar
> (because of the powers he got from Voldemort).
Ken says: Two things here
1. Voldemort has spent the past few years trying to kill Harry,
which I should imagine would destroy his horcrux if indeed he had
been foolish enough to put one there. In fact, when he tried to
kill him as a child he would have destroyed his horcrux then too,
so I think the notion that there is a horcrux anywhere on Harry
is a non starter.
2. You are all assuming that Voldemort has made all his 7
horcruxes already. I would have thought he would be keeping one
for his murder of Harry - that's why he tells the DeathEaters to
lay off Harry and leave him to be dealt with by their master.
Ken
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive