Sympathy to the characters? Fake Moody, Weasleys, Hermione

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 159840

> > Renee:
> > Sorry, but I didn't say anything of the kind; it was Alla who said 
it.
> > I merely wondered how `flawed' could equal `evil'. In my book, 
doing
> > something very bad/idiotic/stupid is still not the same as turning 
evil.

Random: 
> Oh. Well, my message was replying to her - I was confused by the fact
> that you were reacting as if I had been talking about something you
> said. You still missed the fact that I _wasn't_ saying she would turn
> evil, I was rejecting the idea that she wasn't flawed because of 
being
> the author's "alter ego".


Alla:

Yes, but you were rejecting the idea which I was not arguing :) So, I 
am not sure where you are getting this idea from. YES, I agree with 
you - the fact that Hermione is author alter ego does not mean that 
she is not flawed.

What it does mean to me is that she will not turn evil - she can be  
rude, reckless, annoying, anything - I am just not sure that JKR will 
make her alter ego the servant of Voldemort,that's all.

Am I any clearer now? Too bad I cannot find my original message with 
Yahoo stupid threading system, but I thought I was saying the only 
thing there - that Hermione will not turn evil, and even on that I can 
be wrong of course.

JMO,

Alla