Snape and other Sorcerers Stone Musings
Nancy H
nancy.hannah at mac.com
Thu Oct 19 13:49:59 UTC 2006
No: HPFGUIDX 159980
> Lisa:
> After all if you
> remember in the 1st book, Harry's scar hurt at the sight of Snape
>Eddie:
>I think this was a red herring. My recollection of that event is that
>Snape was talking to Quirrell, who was turned towards Snape...
>meaning, the back of Quirrell's head (the Voldemort side) was facing
>Harry. I think it was Voldie who burned Harry's scar.
Lisa,
Eddie is correct. I re-watched SS last night. When Quirrel is
turned, Harry has the pain. In the scene at the end when Quirrel
faces the mirror and Harry is behind him, Harry gets the pain.
Other observations I made on my bizillionth watching:
Anyone thing Mr. Dursley looks incredibly like Wormtail?
Also I jotted down all the numbers , just to see if something popped
out... ( number of bankvaults entered at Gringots etc. So far nothing
is hitting me there. Is there a significance to the 6 sided star on
the floor of Gringots?
Noted Snape, in the scene right after Filch finds "someone is in
restricted section " ( of library)... he finds Quirrel there.
Why was Quirrel, or Snape there in first place, and as Harry tried to
escape under Cloak of Invisibility, Snape is aware that Harry is
there I think. At least he is aware of someone there. Did he give
him the cloak? It was the same handwriting as the original letter
informing of being accepted to Hogwarts.
To me, there is some bond b/t Harry and Snape that is still not
understood, and Snape is protecting him, but hiding that fact by
treating him indifferently. And , at least in this book/ movie, he
appears to show favoritism to Draco, but with a wary eye.
In Olivanders, the Phoenix tail feather story has always stuck in my
mind, since Faulks appears ( sp?) , DD's Phoenix. Seems to me that
is too coincidental. I think the feathers are from his tail. So
maybe we must see who "rises from the ashes."
Oh in this vain... the resemblance to Cinderella in beginning is
unmissable. Harry living with "ugly step brother" and mean step mom.
Does all the chores and then is laying on floor on his birthday in
the hideout of the Dursleys making a Birthday Cake for himself on the
floor in the ashes. I guess this makes Hagrid the Fairy Godmother?
Thanks for indulging my trip back to book 1.
Nancy
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive