I don't think that Harry will die
Hagrid
aussie_lol at yahoo.com.au
Sun Oct 22 13:22:03 UTC 2006
No: HPFGUIDX 160149
"justcarol67" wrote:
>
> Cat wrote:
> > How beautifully eloquent! Harry = Hope. I totally agree Hope
> > can not die. After everything he has been through, all dangers
> > and sorrows, he has never given up. He has earned and deserves a
> > long and happy life!
> >
> > Long Live Harry!
>
> Carol responds:
> Maybe not leave the planet but at least take refuge in Brazil
> ... Seriously, I think that her immense satisfaction in having
> encouraged so many nonreading children to read is
> sufficient to prevent her from killing off Harry because few
> children would want to read about a kid hero they knew was
> going to die ...
>
> Look at the Prophecy: "Neither can live while the other survives.
> ... I predict that, once Voldemort is defeated, Harry will deal
> with a temporary burst of fame ... and then settle down to the
> exciting but not extraordinary life of an Auror in
> training.
Aussie writes:
Ugh. For Harry to be an Auror, he would have to go back and complete
his NEWTs at Hogwarts. That would mean an 8th book. Unfortunately,
there will only be 7 -
- Harry has to die
Also, JKR always lets things subtley slip. Trelawney's predictions
in class have Harry suffering a gruesome and early death. We keep
talking about herprofecy, and her Tarot cards about the tower in
book 6 came true. Will Lavender Brown be able to say, "I told you
so ..." about her support of Trelawney's announcements?
Aussie (who is on a roll at making wrong assumptions)
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive