The Scar

[Goddlefrood]

No: HPFGUIDX 160246

>Jeff wrote:

>I cannot help but feel it is Harry's scar (because of the powers he 
got from Voldemort).

Goddlefrood:

The scar has been discussed many times, quite often in relation to 
its being a Horcrux.

I can't say I buy the theory and having recently spent many hours 
poring through "Horcruxes" to write the chapter discussion on the 
said chapter I am persuaded that JKR has informed us what the 
remainign Horcruxes are and the scar is not one of them.

When, towards the end of his days, Dumbledore frankly told Harry all 
he knew about LV's Horcruxes there was not even a minor hint that 
Dumbledore had any other Horcrux other than the Cup, the Locket, 
Nagini and something of Gryffindor's or Ravenclaw's in mind.

Due to this frankness I am firmly of the view that had Dumbledore 
suspected the scar was a Horcrux he would have said so or named it as 
a possible together with the others. He has moved way beyond 
protecting Harry from distr\urbing information.

Goddlefrood