The Scar

elsa_bard elsa_bard at yahoo.com
Thu Oct 26 16:31:02 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 160391

> Becky Brown:
> Hi Jeff,
> I really don't think Harry is a horcrux.  Voldemort was not able
> to destroy him because Harry's mother sacraficed herself for him.
> But if you think about it.  It would provide JKR with a good way to
> end the series.  With Harry killing Voldemort and then himself to
> keep him from coming back.
>
>

Elsa:

I don't see that as a viable ending for the series. While the books
are wildly popular with adults, ultimately they are written for
children and the concept of suicide by a child for the greater good
is, to my mind, just too heavy. I don't see JKR using a plot device
that is so potentially age inappropriate to her target audience.

Elsa







More information about the HPforGrownups archive