Looking for fellow Snape lovers

[potioncat]

No: HPFGUIDX 160269


> Jenny:
> You are right, Harry did not overhear Dumbledore and Snape
> talking about unbreakable vows.  He heard Snape saying how
> hard things were for him.

Potioncat:
Welcomed to the list, Jenny. I'm not sure if you've had time to 
notice how much we like to nitpick here. Arguing over itty-bitty 
details is what we do best.

So, are you talking about 2 different situations, by chance?

It sounds like you mean the convesation Hagrid overheard and told 
Harry about. Snape didn't want to do something, but DD seemed to be 
holding him to it? Harry didn't hear the actual conversation, he 
heard Hagrid's report of it. Most of are very cautious about 
Hargrid's reporting skills.


Jenny:
 I am not sure if Dumbledore did
> know though.  When Draco was trying to kill Dumbledore,
> Dumbledore said Snape had deceived Draco into thinking the
> vow had been made, but Draco shouted that it had been (which
> it had) so it seemed as if Dumbledore had been duped.  That
> is the most confusing part in the book for me.

Potioncat:
I don't recall whether the vow was real ever being an issue.

Draco was insisting that Snape was really working for LV, not for DD 
and that Snape's only intent by interfering with Draco's plans, was 
so Snape could kill DD himself and steal the glory from Draco.

I'm very sure that DD knew all about the plan all along. But JKR has 
done a nice job of keeping the readers and the different characters 
from knowing what's really going on.

Potioncat, wondering if this makes Snape an Interferius?