Views of Hermione.

[pippin_999]

No: HPFGUIDX 160554

 "justcarol67" <justcarol67@> wrote:
> 
> > It is not the place of a sixteen-year-old
> > to punish anyone 

Eggplant:
> In the corrupt wizard world Hermione lives in there is very little
> connection between justice and the law. So if She doesn't punish a
> traitor who will? Umbridge?

Pippin:
If Hermione does not reform the WW's justice system, who will? 
But nobody is going to support her  if they think she's vindictive 
and powermad. Well, not in the right direction, anyway :)

Eggplant"
> Of all the mistakes Harry has made over 6 books I believe the single
> biggest one was made in book 3 when he stopped Lupin and Black from
> doing what needed to be done. Voldemort would not have been able to
> return and countless people would still be alive.

Pippin:
Oh? Is Pettigrew the only one who could have engineered the
return? Wasn't Barty Crouch Jr already slipping from his daddy's
control and yearning to rejoin his master? Weren't the dementors
already growing restive and weren't there loads of Giants and
Werewolves, among others, who already thought that Voldemort
would give them a better deal? Kill them too? Why not kill
everybody and turn yourself into a snake monster?

I don't see how replacing one torn soul with two makes the
WW a better place. 

Eggplant:> Why? Do you really want your fictional heroes to be bloodless
> passionless goody two shoe fussbudgets?

Pippin:
I have no interest in them being mindless, soulless vigilantes.

Pippin