New Member and question

Eddie harryp at stararcher.com
Sun Oct 29 23:09:09 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 160614

> Stacey: What about the fact that, although not a werewolf
> until bitten as a child, Remus Lupin's name (which I would imagine
was his
> birth name) foretold of his unfortunate condition?  Frankly, there
was no
> AHA! for me as it was a dead giveaway as soon as his full name was first
> spoken.  Prophetic parents?  Name change upon attack?  Thanks!

Eddie:
Prophetic author?  :-D

Actually, lots of the names are puns: Professor Vector (a math term)
teach arithmancy, Professor Sprout (a vegetable) teaches herbology,
Peeves makes people peevish, etc.

Too bad Lupin's name ruined the surprise, though.  I think that pun
was a little too integral to the plot.  The "Sectumsempra" hex is also
guessable if you know enough Latin, but it's a long time between when
it is introduced and when it is used with suprising (to Harry) results.


Eddie







More information about the HPforGrownups archive