Draco is quite the wizard
dumbledore11214
dumbledore11214 at yahoo.com
Tue Oct 31 12:21:24 UTC 2006
No: HPFGUIDX 160727
> > Alla:
> >
> > How does that disprove that Snape showed favoritism to Draco
when
> > said teacher deliberately insults Hermione and then Harry and
Ron
> > start yelling?
>
> zgirnius:
> Because it means he did not do Draco any special favors. He showed
> up, saw some hexing had occured and decided having the victims go
off
> to the hospital wing was the way to handle it. (Note Hermione does
> not get into any trouble for failing to show up in class. I
believe
> this means Snape always intended for her to go get medical
attention,
> just as Goyle did.)
>
> He may have baited Harry, sure. But that's not a favor to Draco;
it
> is something he does, presumably, for his own reasons.
>
Alla:
Um, we do not know that this was not a favor to Draco, for all I
know he absolutely did not plan to ignore that incident but on the
off topic chance that Dumbledore will see this incident in Snape's
head, Snape needed a **reason** to account for punishing Harry and
not punishing Draco, so smart man that he is, since Harry is
completely innocent in the incident, he decides to bait him ( and
what is better way to do so than insult Hermione?) and vo ala, of
course Harry gets upset, who would not? IMO of course.
Alla, who thinks that Snape's special reasons are his hatred of
Harry,who is his father's son,nothing more.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive