Dumbledore's 'evidence' (Was Re: OoP clues?)

[secca_pk]

No: HPFGUIDX 158286

> Abergoat wrote:

<snip>
> But we know from Dumbledore that Snape had 'rejoined' Dumbledore's
> side by this time. I don't think Snape tricked Peter, I think
> Dumbledore asked the Secret-Keeper (ployjuiced Peter) to GIVE the
> secret to Snape since Snape was a spy on Voldemort and therefore 
had > the best chance of learning if Voldemort was looking for 
Sirius (the > supposed Secret-Keeper) <snip>


Secca (formerly Argus Pyrites) responds:

I wanted to throw in my brief two cents... I have nothing to nitpick 
about your theory, Abergoat; it seems as plausible as many floating 
around...but as I read it I must admit to thinking, 'Oh, I hope he's 
not right... polyjuice *again*?

After OotP and Barty/Moody I'm a little polyjuiced out... So, for 
that very subjective reason, I hope the plot doesn't turn that way...

(By the way, sorry about the name change; but I was just picked up 
on staff at Potter's Key's under my screename of 'Secca', and 
recently had a bit of my work show up on the Lexicon under that name 
as well, so makes sense to me to use the same name here...)