Inappropriate charms on a goat

abergoat adescour at pirl.lpl.arizona.edu
Tue Sep 19 02:50:11 UTC 2006


No: HPFGUIDX 158453

houyhnhnm102 wrote:

> So for those of you who are into that, the Aberforth-Roger Bacon 
> connection might be a line of inquiry

Abergoat writes:

Ah, may favorite topics - Aberforth and goats...although I do tend to
merge them more than most people here like, no one's going for the
'Aberfroth is presently a goat' idea.

Your mention of Roger Bacon reminds me of someone earlier's post
suggesting that Albus's relationship with Aberforth might mirror the
Sherlock Holmes series, with Aberforth being intellectually superior
to Albus but completely lacking the interest to use it for society's
betterment.

I thought it was a fun idea. And no matter what anyone says, Albus
Dumbledore only questions whether Aberforth can read...not whether
Aberforth learned to read. The distinction could be quite significant.

Abergoat, fighting the tide







More information about the HPforGrownups archive